INDIAN CINEMA. EVERY LANGUAGE.Meet the talent behind cinema ↗
All We Imagine as Light poster
Drama

All We Imagine as Light

2024 · Malayalam / Hindi / Marathi · 118 MIN

A film by Payal Kapadia

The story

A closer look

Three hospital workers navigate love, loneliness and precarious housing in Mumbai. A journey to a coastal village gives their friendship room to grow and their private desires space to surface.

118 min (Criterion / Janus release)Drama
The Film Nagar review

Private hopes in a crowded city

An affecting portrait of women making room for desire, with colour, restraint and companionship carrying the drama.

Assessment informed by published criticism and film materials. Published 2026-10-03.

9.0/10
The Film Nagar score

Public review consensus

9.4 critics × 80%7.1 audiences × 20%

4 providers · 3 critic inputs · 1 audience input

The available critic average is 9.4/10 and audience average is 7.1/10. These groups differ substantially; the combined score should be read alongside their individual ratings.

How this score is calculated

Published comparable ratings, normalized to ten. Critics carry 80% and public audiences 20% when both groups exist; an available group carries 100%. Providers are equally weighted within each group. Approval percentages and personalized recommendations are excluded. Publications may overlap with aggregator inputs, so this is a provider-level estimate, not a count of independent reviews. Coverage is limited to the researched sources.

ProviderGroupNativeOut of 10WeightContribution
IMDbaudience7.1/107.1020.0%1.420
Metacriticcritic93/1009.3026.7%2.480
NDTVcritic4.5/59.0026.7%2.400
The Guardiancritic5/510.0026.7%2.667

Contributions use full precision, then the total is rounded to one decimal. Provider weights are not based on vote counts. Published aggregators can include the same reviews as individual publications; overlap cannot be fully removed without their underlying review lists.

The Film Nagar method ↗

Six dimensions of the film

Our craft assessments draw on written criticism. They are separate from the public consensus above.

Story & screenplay 8.5 /10

Interwoven desires give everyday decisions weight.

Direction 9.0 /10

Reality and imagination share a coherent emotional purpose.

Performances 9.0 /10

Kusruti makes withheld emotion legible.

Visual craft 9.0 /10

Colour gives ordinary places psychological depth.

Editing & pacing 8.5 /10

Patient transitions favour accumulation over surprise.

Music & sound 8.5 /10

Displaced voices enlarge the visible city.

Read the full assessment

Payal Kapadia connects romantic uncertainty to the practical pressures of work, housing and migration. Prabha, Anu and Parvaty inhabit the same city differently; their growing solidarity gives this episodic narrative its emotional centre.

The strongest evidence for the film's achievement lies in its precise, modest gestures. Kani Kusruti's restrained response to a gift from abroad makes absence tangible, while the blue city palette and separation of voices from images complicate an apparently straightforward realism.

The later coastal passage makes space for wish and imagination. That movement is persuasive as emotional release, although its symbolism is more familiar than the specificity of the Mumbai scenes. The measured rhythm rewards attention to changing relationships rather than dramatic surprises.

Where it connects

Expressive restraint and carefully connected emotional and physical spaces.

Where it may divide

The coastal release is less distinctive than the urban detail.

Across the public reviews

Published ratings

Dated snapshots · native scales

Critics

Individual critic ratingAs of 2024-05-24 · 1 review

Audiences

IMDb ↗7.1/10
Public audience averageAs of 2026-03-09 · 14,000 ratings
Coverage & streaming ratings

These are the verified ratings currently available for this title, not a complete census of internet reviews. Historical ratings may differ from today’s provider pages. A percentage of positive reviews is shown for context and does not enter the score.

Prime Video customer ratings are audience input where a public aggregate is available. IMDb displayed on a streaming page counts as IMDb once. Netflix’s personalized recommendations are individual predictions and cannot be used as a public film rating. Country selection under Watch & Listen changes provider searches, not these rating snapshots.

Loading cast & crew…